Gisele Bundchen and Smart vs. Sexist Responses
I am happy that GB and her hunky footballer husband have found love and made a beautiful baby. I do not care what her opinion on breastfeeding is. Partly because it’s a personal decision and partly because breastfeeding isn’t on my radar.
She thinks there should be a worldwide law requiring breastfeeding for the first six months? Awesome! That’s stupid. She’s since backpedaled…sort of. In so much as she mentions opening a discussion. As though women’s choices in general and especially as mothers aren’t already scrutinized under the cultural microscope.
But here’s the thing. Even though I don’t agree with her on the issue, and even though I wish she hadn’t spoken as though her experience should be every woman’s experience, I am once again dismayed by the responses that seem to pop up whenever a famous woman dares to open her mouth.
Readers of the CNN Marquee Blog (Dear CNN, that blog is the opposite of news.) had a lot to say about Bundchen’s initial interview. I have no doubt many of the quotes were thoughtful expressions of frustration, but CNN chose to use the kind of problematic statements that shoot steam out of my ears.
“Classic ignorant statement by someone who is only known because of how she looks in her bra and panties…”
She is a model who is famous primarily for her work as a Victoria’s Secret model. She made some “ignorant” statements (though they’re not what I would call ignorant, more misguided and judgmental). Those two things? Are not related.
“It’s love that matters, not where the milk comes from. So, stop doing public appearances and magazine shoots, and raise your baby.”
Yes, it is love that matters. And love has zero to do with whether Bundchen or any woman chooses to work outside the home, provided she even has a choice.
“Do your own research but please don’t get your information from some model that just popped out a kid and now she thinks she’s an expert…”
Again with the that makes sense statement followed by the come on now, don’t be an a-hole statement. Yes, women should determine for themselves if breastfeeding is the right decision. But “just some model who popped out a kid”? How’s about we leave her profession out of it…and the phrase “popped out a kid.” Thanks.
This is a blip of a story that won’t play much longer especially now that Bundchen has apologized. But the reactions? Those stem from something deeper. Something ugly.
Oh, and as for a smart response, I can’t believe I’m going to say this, but I thought the Ladies of the View (tm ABC’s marketing department of cliches) had thoughtful and reasonable reactions despite their anger. Which ranks with, “Hugh Hefner is my hero,” as the statement I’m least likely to make without a major personality change.
*I haven’t read anywhere that Gisele Bundchen breastfed for three weeks. Joy Behar probably confused her with Denise van Outen who said that she breastfed for three weeks because of concerns about the paparazzi. What Behar should have said is that none of these women’s choices are our business.




















