The Strange Case of Gerard Butler
I watched 300 Monday night, and despite issues I have with the movie’s racial and gender politics, Gerard Butler is a star in it. Charismatic, strong, and even funny. Which, in a movie filled with bloodletting of various severity, is no small thing.
Ever since the release of the film, the man who would be king of the box office hasn’t released anything that isn’t a complete dud. (Okay, I will admit to loving P.S. I Love You. Shut up.) I figured I’d go back to some of the movies that started him on his path to 300 and the films that have stripped him of all the credibility the movie gained him.
Her Majesty, Mrs. Brown
His first IMDB credit. It’s a small part, but he’s great in it and not because he shows his hindquarters. Ahem, not just because he shows his hindquarters. It’s hard to stand out in a movie with Billy Connolly and Judi Dench, but anyone who thinks he can’t act should start here.
Tomorrow Never Dies
I had no idea Butler played Leading Seaman-HMS Devonshire in TND. It’s my favorite pre-Craig Bond film, so…yay Butler.
Blah, Blah, Blah, Bunch of Stuff I’ve Never Heard Of
Dracula 2000
Wowza. I know Butler had to eat, but come on. It’s a vampire movie with Danny Masterson from That ’70s Show and the least scary bloodsuckers since Bunnicula. GB scores back a few cool points by going head to head with Christopher Plummer as Van Helsing. Who wins in a fight between King Leonides and Captain Von Trapp? Serious question.
Doo Da Dooo More Stuff
Reign of Fire
GB’s involvement is overshadowed in every way by the mondo-uber-weirdo-machismo character that Matthew McConaughey inflicts on the audience.
Lara Croft Tomb Raider: The Cradle of Life
This is a not great sequel to a ho hum film. Gerard Butler does horizontal pull-ups on the ceiling of his prison cell. Angelina Jolie acts bored and almost sleeps with him. That really is all there is to recommend it.
Timeline
Haaahahha. Hoo boy, this one is bad. But in a good way. Scientists jump back in time to try to save Billy Connolly (who stepped WAY down from Mrs Brown.) Gerard Butler gets to be all romantic times with a lady in olden times and the costumes and sets are fun. However, those of you thinking that the movie sounds like silly fun should remember two words. Paul. Walker.
Dear Frankie
You have not seen this movie. You should see this movie. Butler plays a The Stranger. Wait, wait, stay with me. A woman who has spent the better part of 10 years lying to her son about his father’s whereabouts hires Butler to play the part of Dad for a weekend. Maudlin sappiness ensues yes, but Emily Mortimer is lovely as the overprotective mother who does something desperate. And Butler and Jack McElhone as Frankie act like real people as they get to know each other rather than film cliches.
The Phantom of the Opera
Allow me a moment to speak directly to the man himself…Hey Gerald, sup? So, listen, I know it might seem like a good idea to star in a film as a disfigured man in love with a breathy, sweet-faced ingenue. Your agent might have even told you that it was Oscar material. Your publicist promised you magazine covers. Fire them. Fire everyone who told you this bloated, preening mess of movie musical would do anything but make you look like a putz. Cause you did, you know. Look like a putz. A putz in a mask.
Skipping ahead to….
300
GRRRRRRR. I’m making a Spartan face. ARRRGGGGHHHHH. And I’m done.
P.S. I Love You
Shut UP, it’s sweet. And Kathy Bates is wonderful and looks a lot like Hilary Swank. Harry Connick Jr.! Jeffrey Dean Morgan! Gina Gershon! James Marsters! Seriously, people. Spike from Buffy. GB’s role is small but pivotal. If the dude didn’t die, his widow would never have the impetus to go to Ireland and start designing shoes and make nice with her mom. Really, his death in this is almost as noble as his death in 300. Really.
RocknRolla
Haven’t seen it. Dig the title.
The Ugly Truth
I watched this…movie. I can’t think of how to describe it without saying awful things about the writers’, producers’ and actors’ progeny and ancestors. If the world was fair, everyone involved including Butler would have to spend a year volunteering at a local Planned Parenthood, or homeless shelter, or animal rescue to reset the karmic balance upset by this crap. Gerry, you make me sad.
Gamer
This movie is not about what I would like it to be about. An overly muscled man who thinks he’s a Spartan warrior, joins a D&D group, and convinces them to invade the local Jamba Juice.
The Bounty Hunter
Everything in my feminist soul wanted to go HULK SMASH whenever I saw the trailer for this piece of blech. King Leonides is looking pretty far away, dude.
I’m ending it there. At the apex of his career immolation.





















